Orange County’s Board of Supervisors deadlocked 2-2 on Tuesday over whether to induct John Wayne into the county’s Hall of Fame, killing the bid after the board chairman abstained from voting.
The push to honor the Hollywood icon ran into organized opposition from the NAACP, whose representatives urged supervisors to reject Wayne’s inclusion. They pointed to a 1971 Playboy interview in which Wayne made comments endorsing white supremacy.
“I believe in white supremacy until the blacks are educated to a point of responsibility. I don’t believe in giving authority and positions of leadership and judgment to irresponsible people,” Wayne told the magazine.
In the same interview, Wayne defended the taking of Native American land, saying: “I don’t feel we did wrong in taking this great country away from them, if that’s what you’re asking.”
Supervisor Don Wagner fought to save Wayne’s induction, telling colleagues the actor’s entire life shouldn’t be reduced to one magazine article from more than 50 years ago.
“Certainly, John Wayne’s legacy writ large is not what you find in a Playboy magazine article where John Wayne’s comments definitely clang off the modern ear,” Wagner said.
Wagner rejected the characterization of Wayne as a racist or white supremacist, noting the actor married minority women multiple times over his life.
“To even suggest John Wayne was racist and a white supremacist is a little off given his history, especially if you take out that one admittedly disturbing Playboy article. The man was married multiple times to minority women,” Wagner said.
He also compared the standard being applied to Wayne to how history treats other major American figures, invoking Abraham Lincoln, Martin Luther King Jr. and the Kennedy brothers as examples of leaders whose records include controversy.
The deadlock means Wayne will not join the Hall of Fame this cycle. The board did approve nine other inductees, including musician Dexter Holland, chemist and businessman Arnold Beckman, and Justice Eileen Moore.