Nobody owes anyone an explanation for how they spend Thanksgiving. Across New York City, a growing number of people are opting out of the crowded flights, the forced family seating charts and the political arguments over mashed potatoes — and choosing instead to spend the holiday exactly how they want to, alone or on their own terms.
The market has responded. Restaurants in all five boroughs are now offering full Thanksgiving meals for solo diners, most for well under $100, giving New Yorkers a real alternative to the obligatory family gathering.
Cara Torchia, 26, a Manhattan-based content creator and actress, is spending her third straight solo Thanksgiving in the city this year. “I spent two NYC Thanksgivings solo, and this will be my third one solo,” she told The Post. On her first, she watched crews inflate the Macy’s parade balloons on Columbus Avenue, stocked up at West Side Market, then cooked herself a full spread — turkey, ham, stuffing, mashed potatoes, green beans and more — while watching the parade from her apartment.
“It’s normal to feel a little sad and have some FOMO, but I appreciate that I can enjoy my own company and make the best of it,” she said.
Brooke Johnson, 30 — the first woman recognized for skateboarding across America — ended up spending her first NYC Thanksgiving alone in 2023 after a relationship fell through. “He wasn’t ready for me to meet the parents,” she said. Instead, she skated up to watch the Macy’s parade in person. “I moseyed my way up there, brought my skateboard and had a freaking blast,” she told The Post. “I learned that in New York, you’re never alone, only if you want to be.”
Mental health professionals say there’s nothing wrong with choosing solitude over obligation. NYC psychiatrist Dr. Erika Balfour told The Post that “spending Thanksgiving alone can feel difficult for people as it is billed as a family-based holiday,” but added there’s “no need to feel guilty about choosing solitude.”
Therapist Jessica Thomas said the key is honesty with yourself about what you actually want — rest, connection, freedom, or simply a break from other people’s expectations. “Reframing only works when it’s true. You don’t have to pretend you’re thrilled,” she said. “You can love where you come from and still decide what you can carry this year.” For relatives demanding an explanation, her advice is simple: “I’m staying in the city this Thanksgiving.”
Where to eat solo this Thanksgiving, by borough
- EJ’s Luncheonette, Upper East Side — $48.95: Roasted turkey, cornbread stuffing, mashed potatoes, Brussels sprouts, cranberry sauce, gravy, soup or salad, and apple or pumpkin pie. Call (212) 472-0600.
- SoHo Diner, SoHo — $45: Roasted turkey, sourdough stuffing, mashed potatoes, garlic green beans, cranberry sauce and gravy, plus brown-butter pumpkin or Petee’s apple pie. Reservations via Resy recommended.
- Havana Central, Times Square — $39 (or $69 prix fixe): Choice of turkey, ropa vieja or pernil with stuffing, mashed yuca, roasted vegetables and cranberry salsita. Blocks from the parade route.
- The Elgin, Midtown — $29: Thanksgiving turkey burger with mushroom-walnut stuffing, cranberry-apple relish, pickled mustard seeds and fries. Call (212) 221-2100 for solo reservations.
- Levant on Smith, Boerum Hill — $75: Three-course prix fixe with a complimentary drink, turkey or other mains, and pumpkin pie or espresso crème brûlée.
- Palo Santo, Park Slope — $85: Three-course Pan-Latin feast with mole-braised turkey or chile relleno, plus an optional $35 wine flight.
- The Queensboro, Jackson Heights — $88: Curried cauliflower soup, maple butter bread, and a choice of roasted turkey, beef pot roast, stuffed trout or vegetarian stuffed onion.
- Victory Garden Cafe, Astoria — $54.95: Greek-style turkey, baby lamb chops, or shrimp scampi, each with Greek salad.
- Da Noi, Rosebank, Staten Island — $39.95: Sliced turkey breast with homemade gravy, sweet mashed potatoes and ground beef stuffing. Call (718) 720-1650.
- Italianissimo, South Beach, Staten Island — $67: Four-course Italian-American dinner with roast turkey, chestnut-sausage stuffing or other mains, dessert included.
- Wicked Wolf Bronx, Throggs Neck — $52.14+: Four-course sit-down dinner with herb-roasted turkey, turkey pot pie, salmon or chicken parmigiana. Reservations required: (718) 829-4400.
- Lena Trattoria, Throggs Neck — $85: Prix fixe with roasted turkey, prime New York strip, braised veal osso bucco or seafood, two sides and dessert.
Whatever the reason — cost, distance, family friction, or simply a preference for peace and quiet — spending the holiday on your own terms is a legitimate choice, not a failure to explain to anyone.