New York’s comedy clubs don’t get the same tax break as Broadway theaters, bowling alleys, movie theaters, the circus, or even singles networking events. Comedian Jim Gaffigan and a bipartisan-in-spirit group of state lawmakers want that to change, and they rallied Thursday at The Stand comedy club in Manhattan to pressure Gov. Kathy Hochul into signing a bill that would finally fix it.
The New York State Legislature passed the bill unanimously back in June. It would exempt comedy performances from the state’s sales tax on admissions, the same exemption already granted to a long list of other entertainment venues. The bill has been sitting on Hochul’s desk since then, and advocates want her signature before the end of the year.
“It really comes down to comedians need people to be able to afford to go to a show,” Gaffigan told Fox News Digital at Thursday’s rally. “And [not having] this unnecessary tax that Broadway shows don’t have to deal with makes it more palatable for someone to pay.”
“Particularly given the economic times, people might come out, but if they see the sales tax, even if it moves the bill up a little bit, that might dissuade them from coming back,” he added.
A Legal Gray Area Turned Audit Target
Supporters of the bill say the tax gap is a legacy of an era when New York City’s stand-up scene wasn’t taken as seriously as other performing arts, and it’s now being weaponized against small businesses. Paul Italia, co-owner of The Stand and the newly opened The Stand West, laid out the absurdity: if Gaffigan performs at his club, customers pay sales tax. If Gaffigan performs the identical set days later at a venue classified as a theater, they don’t.
“There was a gray area, and a lot of us have not been collecting sales tax. And recently, the state decided to come — I don’t want to say come after us — but in audits, this has come up many times,” Italia told Fox News Digital.
“We are being asked to pay for money that we never collected, because we never charged the sales tax, some of us, and that hurts a great deal. In fact, if it continues to go that way, I think it would cause a bit of a strain on some of our businesses, comedy clubs, that we may not be able to overcome.”
Lawmakers From Both Wings Say Fix It
New York Assemblymember Keith Powers, a Democrat who sponsored the Assembly version of the bill, said the current rules leave small venues exposed to sudden tax audits that can produce a “gigantic financial liability” severe enough to shut a club down.
“I can’t defend why comedy clubs would be left out of it if everyone else is receiving it, so why not now?” Powers said.
State Sen. Kristen Gonzalez, who sponsored the Senate version and describes herself as a democratic socialist, called the fix “common sense” — and didn’t shy away from the irony of her position.
“As much as I’m a democratic socialist, and I was able to make that joke … I also think it’s fair to support our small businesses, our artists and, that as a state representative of a district that has so many of them, this is part of my job and duty to my constituents.”
Gonzalez’s message to the governor was blunt: “Sign the bill, please.”
Gaffigan framed the stakes in simpler terms, pointing to New York City’s role as a hub for stand-up. “New York City is very important for stand-up comedy, so I selfishly want that to be fed and supported,” he said. “I think that Governor Hochul understands that.”
A spokesperson for Hochul told Fox News Digital only that “the Governor will review the bill.” No timeline was given.