‘Gilded Age’ Wedding Scene Reignites Debate Over Origins of ‘Jumping the Broom’

‘Gilded Age’ Wedding Scene Reignites Debate Over Origins of ‘Jumping the Broom’

Follow America's fastest-growing news aggregator, Spreely News, and stay informed. You can find all of our articles plus information from your favorite Conservative voices. 

HBO’s “The Gilded Age” built its Season 4, Episode 3 wedding around a single prop: a broom. In “Ain’t That Good News,” Peggy Scott (Denée Benton) and Dr. William Kirkland (Jordan Donica) marry, then jump over the same broom her parents, Dorothy (Audra McDonald) and Arthur (John Douglas Thompson), used at their own wedding.

The scene almost didn’t happen on screen. William’s mother, Elizabeth Kirkland (Phylicia Rashad), objects the moment Arthur hands Peggy the broom, calling it a relic of slave culture she wants nothing to do with. The disagreement drives a wedge between the two families until William backs his in-laws and the couple goes through with the tradition.

Stars Audra McDonald and Denée Benton told Decider the writers, Sonya Warfield and Julian Fellowes, used that friction deliberately rather than letting the scene play as pure sentiment.

“It could have just been a sweet moment, but the fact that Sonya and Julian thought to write in the conflict of the Kirklands absolutely looking down on it and saying, ‘We’re not going to do this. This isn’t right and it’s beneath us,’ is great to play, of course. But I think what’s more is it causes Dorothy and Arthur to defend who they are, and show pride in who they are and what they came from.” — Audra McDonald

Jumping the broom is widely understood as a practice forced on enslaved Black people who were barred from marriages recognized by church or state. That history is why the Kirklands, who have never been enslaved and have long held higher social status, resist it.

“I think that all those conversations are so dynamic and important, not just to show the kind of whimsical jubilee, but to see that people really paid a cost to stay in touch with who they were… So I love that Mrs. Kirkland is kind of an oppositional force to show how vital and important that preservation actually is.” — Denée Benton

Benton tied the scene to a broader pattern she sees in the show, where characters shed their origins to gain acceptance into high society. She pointed to a Season 1 line mocking Bertha as “just a potato digger’s daughter,” a jab at her Irish heritage.

“So I think for Peggy to be a representative of someone who’s being very proud of where she came from as she rises to the top… it’s really special to show all of the ways that we were vibrantly living and creating these really singular, stunning spaces.” — Denée Benton

McDonald called jumping the broom “a beautiful tradition that did exist,” and said getting to show it as “a glorious moment in the wedding” mattered to her.

Where the tradition actually comes from

The history is less settled than popular belief suggests. According to The Knot, the custom is commonly believed to have originated with enslaved African people, but historians disagree on its roots. Dianne M. Stewart, a professor of religion and African American studies at Emory University, wrote in a 2021 piece for Oprah Daily that the broomstick ritual has actually been traced to European wedding customs, which slave owners then imposed on enslaved people.

Stewart also suggested that ABC’s miniseries “Roots,” which depicted a broomstick wedding, may have shaped how widespread the public assumes the practice was. She asked whether that portrayal should be seen “not as the standard wedding ritual, but as one of many practiced by African captives.”

Still, there is historical evidence that many Black people did marry by jumping the broom, even if not in the numbers often assumed today. In the show, Peggy’s parents married that way, and she and Dr. Kirkland worked the custom into their own ceremony to honor that legacy.

New episodes of “The Gilded Age” Season 4 air Sundays at 9 p.m. on HBO and HBO Max.

Share:

GET MORE STORIES LIKE THIS

IN YOUR INBOX!

Sign up for our daily email and get the stories everyone is talking about.

Discover more from Liberty One News

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading