A Pinellas County judge sentenced former plastic surgeon Tomasz Kosowski, 47, to death Friday for murdering attorney Cozzi, whose body has never been recovered, court records show.
Judge Joseph Bulone imposed the sentence after rejecting a last-minute bid from Kosowski, who represented himself in the case, to have Bulone removed from the proceedings.
“The court has given great weight to the aggravating factor that the homicide was committed in a cold, calculated and premeditated manner, without any pretense of moral or legal justification,” Bulone said in court, according to FOX 13 Tampa Bay.
Bulone found that the nature of the killing alone outweighed any mitigating factors Kosowski’s defense raised. In September, following a non-jury trial, Bulone had already found Kosowski guilty of first-degree murder.
The two men’s paths crossed through a 2019 civil lawsuit over medical billing money Kosowski claimed he was owed. Cozzi represented the corporate clients Kosowski had sued, and prosecutors said Kosowski’s hostility toward the attorney built over years of litigation.
Cozzi vanished on March 21, 2023, just minutes before a 10 a.m. teleconference hearing in that case. He left behind his phone, keys and wallet at his desk at the Blanchard Law Firm in Largo, according to court records.
Prosecutors said Kosowski killed Cozzi in the firm’s bathroom, where investigators found spattered blood mixed with Kosowski’s DNA. They said Kosowski then wheeled Cozzi’s remains out in a wagon covered with a reddish-orange blanket and loaded them into a silver Toyota Tundra.
Surveillance footage tracked the truck to Kosowski’s home in Tarpon Springs. A search warrant there turned up Cozzi’s DNA in the truck bed and on the garage floor, along with a vial of the paralytic drug succinylcholine linked to Kosowski’s Miami plastic surgery practice, court records show.
Cellphone records placed Kosowski near a dumpster in Collier County, close to the Everglades. Investigators searched a landfill where the dumpster’s contents had been taken, after more than 6,000 tons of garbage had already been piled onto the load, prosecutors said.
Cozzi’s remains were never found. The Public Defender’s Office has now been appointed to represent Kosowski in his appeal, according to court records.