FCC Chairman Brendan Carr is being urged to tear up a set of radio ownership limits that have not changed in any meaningful way since 1996 — a year before the first iPod shipped and before satellite radio existed at all. The case for scrapping those caps comes from attorney Mike Davis, who argues in a new op-ed that Washington is choking off the very local stations that keep rural and small-town America informed.
The rules in question, set by Congress in 1996, cap how many stations a single company may own in a market on a sliding scale. In the largest markets, a company generally cannot own more than eight stations total, and no more than five in either the AM or FM band. Smaller markets face even tighter limits.
Davis’s argument is simple: those caps were written for a media landscape that no longer exists. Local radio stations today compete directly with Spotify, SiriusXM, YouTube, podcasts and social media giants — none of which face any federal cap on how much of a local audience they can capture. A listener driving to work chooses between a hometown morning show, a podcast and a streaming playlist in the same ten minutes. That, Davis says, is one marketplace, not a protected category walled off from Big Tech.
The stakes go beyond market share. Running a station — newsroom staff, towers, backup generators, engineers, on-air talent — costs real money that a single standalone station often cannot cover alone. Davis argues that letting stations share those costs across a larger group is what keeps emergency alerts on the air, high school games broadcast and crop and livestock reports reaching farmers who rely on them.
That lifeline matters most when everything else fails. A battery-powered radio keeps working through tornadoes, floods, wildfires and cell network outages — the exact moments when a nationwide streaming app is useless and a local broadcaster who knows the roads, schools and shelters is not.
Davis pushes back preemptively on the obvious objection — that loosening caps invites monopoly. He notes that removing the arbitrary ownership limits would not strip the FCC of its authority to review station purchases, nor would it touch the Justice Department’s antitrust power over radio deals. What it would end, he argues, is a system that treats a locally run station as a bigger threat than a nationwide tech platform reaching nearly every smartphone in the country.
He’s equally skeptical of the idea that federal bureaucrats can engineer