The man in charge of the College Football Playoff says the committee that ranks college football teams will not explain the criteria behind those rankings, and does not consider it feasible to do so.
CFP Executive Director Ryan Clark made the admission in an interview with The Athletic’s Chris Vannini, after fans demanded to know why the Selection Committee’s rankings put nine SEC teams in the top 25 while leaving Alabama untouched no matter the result.
“Just to let you know, we have not provided those publicly,” Clark said. “Basically, there are so many metrics, to really give that out publicly with an explanation of them isn’t really feasible now. It is something that we’re considering. We’re looking at this in the off-season to see what metrics and how we would present those potentially in coming seasons.”
In plain terms: the committee that decides which teams make the postseason in a multi-billion-dollar sport will not say how it makes that decision. Clark frames it as a complexity problem. Fans watching the actual results on the field see something else.
Consider what the committee’s hidden metrics have produced this season. Tennessee beat Alabama head-to-head and holds the same record as the Tide, yet sits six spots below them in the rankings. South Carolina, with four losses, remains in the top 25 despite getting routed by a 3-6 Arkansas team.
Whatever internal formula allows those two outcomes to stand is exactly the kind of thing a public explanation would expose to scrutiny. That may be the point. A committee that has to show its work can be held to it. A committee that keeps its criteria secret cannot.
Clark’s comments make clear he feels no pressure to change that arrangement. Nothing in his answer suggests the committee intends to release its criteria this season, only that it is “considering” how it might present metrics “in coming seasons.” Fans demanding accountability now are being told to wait.
That leaves the sport’s postseason fate in the hands of a panel accountable to no one but itself, deciding which programs play for a championship using standards it refuses to put in writing.