Christina Applegate says she now suspects her breast implants, not multiple sclerosis, may be responsible for years of debilitating symptoms. The revelation comes weeks after the actress disclosed she had been misdiagnosed with MS.
Applegate, who had a double mastectomy in 2008 following a breast cancer diagnosis, raised the possibility on the Nov. 10 episode of her podcast “MeSsy,” which she co-hosts with actress and MS advocate Jamie-Lynn Sigler. She said she believes her implants are overdue for replacement and recently came across research suggesting implant-related illness can mimic MS.
“And I swear, over the last five years or whatever, I thought, ‘What if they’re leaking, and they’re like poisoning me?'” Applegate said.
She has not confirmed the implants as the cause and said she plans to raise the issue with her doctors. Her symptoms have included joint pain, trouble getting out of bed, and an inability to lift her right arm.
“I don’t know what’s going on in my joints, but I can’t move my right shoulder at all now,” she said. “I can’t lift my arm.”
Applegate said she and her doctors are now working through other conditions that share symptoms with MS, including rheumatoid arthritis, lupus and Lyme disease.
“We’re going into square one, just doing some testing and going one by one [through] the sister diseases to MS,” she said. “It’s overwhelming because there are so many different things that could be going on and this pain stuff.”
A condition without clear answers
Diana Zuckerman, president of the National Center for Health Research in Washington, D.C., said breast implant illness is finally being taken more seriously after years of being dismissed.
“It’s a range of symptoms, and not everybody has the same symptoms,” Zuckerman told Fox News Digital. “And some of them are pretty common, such as joint pain or chronic fatigue. Some women talk about feeling like they’ve had the flu for [months].”
She said patients also report brain fog, memory issues, anxiety, insomnia, and muscle pain and weakness — symptoms that overlap with numerous other conditions. Women affected are often young, she said, yet feel decades older than their age.
“They’re often very young women who are in their 20s, and suddenly they feel like they’re in their 50s — that’s how they describe it,” Zuckerman said.
She added that research has shown some women recover dramatically once implants are removed.
Jonathan Kaplan, a board-certified plastic surgeon at Pacific Heights Plastic Surgery in San Francisco, said the symptoms are real but there’s no test that predicts who will get sick.
“While patients may have abnormal blood tests to support their concerns about having some type of illness, these lab tests would not predict ahead of time if the patient is more or less likely to have issues if they choose to get implants,” Kaplan said.
Kaplan said patients should first rule out other treatable causes, including MS or medication side effects, before assuming implants are to blame.
“The cause could be due to breast implants, but the only way to confirm that is to remove the implants and see if the patient improves,” he said. “If they do not, then they may have unnecessarily undergone a surgical procedure that did not benefit them.”
Kaplan said he once treated a patient who developed fatigue and abnormal bloodwork suggesting kidney failure years after getting implants. Once she had them removed, her symptoms resolved and her labs normalized — but he said there was no way to have predicted that outcome beforehand.
Kaplan also noted there is currently no evidence that MS itself is affected by the presence or absence of breast implants.
No diagnostic test, no official recognition
Patricia McGuire, a St. Louis-based plastic surgeon and chair of the Breast Implant Emergency Task Force, said more than 100 symptoms have been linked to breast implant illness by patients, but the condition remains medically unrecognized.
“They have no abnormal labs or physical findings, and there is no diagnostic criteria,” McGuire told Fox News Digital. “It is a diagnosis of exclusion and is not a currently recognized illness.”
McGuire said symptoms have been reported with every type of implant — silicone gel, saline, smooth and textured — regardless of manufacturer, and that the underlying cause is unknown.
“We do not know the cause,” she said. “The suggestions have been heavy metals from the implants entering the body, bacterial biofilms, fungal infections, allergic reactions, immune response to a foreign body and neuropsychiatric conditions. We also know that some patients may get better with implant removal.”
In a blinded study McGuire co-led with Dr. Caroline Glicksman, researchers found no biological differences — no elevated heavy metals, bacteria or inflammatory markers — between women reporting breast implant illness and symptom-free control groups. Instead, the condition correlated strongly with elevated anxiety, somatic symptom patterns and heavy reliance on social media for medical information, even though patients did experience genuine relief after implant removal.
“To be honest, we were disappointed that we did not find an easily reversible cause, or that we did not find a blood value that could be used to make a diagnosis or point to the cause of symptoms in these patients,” McGuire said. “We have a couple of pilot studies in the works, hoping we can find something definitive.”
In 2021, the FDA imposed new rules requiring a boxed warning and a mandatory patient decision checklist for all breast implants, explicitly listing fatigue, memory loss, rash, brain fog and joint pain as possible systemic symptoms that may resolve after removal.
Implants are not lifetime devices. The FDA recommends MRI or ultrasound screening starting five to six years after surgery, repeated every two to three years, to detect silent ruptures — though implants have no fixed expiration date if intact and the patient has no symptoms.
McGuire advised anyone with implants experiencing symptoms to get a full medical workup to rule out reversible causes before pursuing surgery, and to consult a board-certified plastic surgeon with breast surgery experience if considering removal.