Appeals Court Blocks Trump Bid to Yank Highway Funds Over Illegal Migrant Trucker Licenses

Appeals Court Blocks Trump Bid to Yank Highway Funds Over Illegal Migrant Trucker Licenses

Follow America's fastest-growing news aggregator, Spreely News, and stay informed. You can find all of our articles plus information from your favorite Conservative voices. 

A federal appeals court has ruled that New York does not have to lose highway funding over its refusal to immediately strip commercial driver’s licenses from illegal aliens, dealing a setback to a Trump administration push to get states to comply with new residency-based licensing rules.

A three-judge panel of the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled last week that New York cannot be held to the administration’s new regulation retroactively. The panel consisted of Biden appointees Alison J. Nathan and Sarah A. L. Merriam, and Trump appointee Matthew A. Schwartz.

Earlier this year, the Trump administration rewrote federal regulations to require states to account for a migrant’s legal residency status before issuing commercial driver’s licenses (CDLs), and to ensure those licenses expire no later than the end of a migrant’s legal residency. The change followed findings that thousands of migrants held valid licenses even after they were no longer legally permitted to live in the United States, allowing them to keep working as commercial truck drivers despite having no legal status.

The federal government argued the requirement was already implied under prior law, since a migrant cannot legally work once their status ends or is revoked. The appeals court rejected that argument, finding the new rule could not be applied to conduct that predated it.

The dispute landed in court after the Departments of Homeland Security and Transportation ordered New York and other states to cancel CDLs held by non-domiciled drivers to bring them into compliance with the new rule. New York refused, and instead sued the federal agencies to block enforcement and preserve its ability to keep issuing commercial licenses to illegal migrants.

In response, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration moved to withhold four percent of New York’s federal-aid highway funding — close to $74 million, according to Newsweek.

New York argued in court that the funding could not legally be withheld because the new rule could not be applied to licensing decisions made before it existed. The appeals court agreed, ruling that “the agency could not withhold federal funding based on a state’s noncompliance with a regulatory requirement that did not exist.”

Notably, even Trump-appointed Judge Schwartz sided with New York on this point, concluding the case had to be decided according to the statutes in effect at the time — and those statutes said nothing about tying licenses to legal residency dates.

The ruling applies narrowly to the withholding of transportation funding. A separate lawsuit challenging the underlying rule — which ties CDL validity to a migrant’s legal residency status — is still working its way through the courts.

Share:

GET MORE STORIES LIKE THIS

IN YOUR INBOX!

Sign up for our daily email and get the stories everyone is talking about.

Discover more from Liberty One News

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading